English Language & Usage Asked on December 21, 2021
I’m struggling with this sentence fragment: “…and produces usually one, sometimes multiple, binary outputs.” Is this grammatically correct? Is there a better way to structure this?
Here is the entire sentence:
In electronics, a logic gate is an idealized or physical device implementing a Boolean function; that is, it performs a logical operation on one or more binary inputs and produces usually one, sometimes multiple binary outputs.
Since a Boolean function produces one binary output by definition, it's not really correct to say what you're trying to say.
How about something like this:
In electronics, a logic gate is usually an idealized or physical device implementing a Boolean function; that is, it performs a logical operation on one or more binary inputs and produces a binary output. Sometimes devices that produce multiple binary outputs are also referred to as gates if _______.
I leave the blank blank, because I'm not actually familiar with anything that has multiple outputs that I would refer to as a "gate". Latches and flip-flops, for example, would be circuits composed of multiple gates.
Answered by Matt Timmermans on December 21, 2021
. . . and produces usually one, sometimes multiple, binary outputs.
The problem with this is that you're using parenthetical information—and you're allowing it to change the grammar of the surrounding text, something that you should not do.
The phrase sometimes multiple is nonrestrictive.
The essential part of the sentence is this:
✘ . . . and produces usually one binary outputs.
In order for it to be strictly grammatical, the final word needs to be in the singular:
✘ . . . and produces usually one, sometimes multiple, binary output.
However, despite it's technical correctness, it sounds so bad that it shouldn't be used either.
You could rewrite it in a fashion similar to this:
✔ . . . and usually produces a single binary output—but sometimes more.
However, I think the most effective way is to rephrase it so the final part of the sentence takes a parallel form with what comes before:
✔ In electronics, a logic gate is an idealized or physical device implementing a Boolean function; that is, it performs a logical operation on one or more binary inputs and produces usually one but sometimes multiple binary outputs.
To explain, this is allowed:
one or more binary inputs
Even though the phrase starts with one, inputs is closest to a plural noun—so it takes a plural form.
Similarly, we have this:
usually one but sometimes multiple binary outputs
Also, we can make this grammatical change because there is no parenthetical, nonrestrictive information that should not be affecting the surrounding grammar.
Answered by Jason Bassford on December 21, 2021
I would change the sentence entirely.
[...] and produces a certain, predefined, number of binary outputs.
or
[...] and produces at least one binary output.
Answered by NofP on December 21, 2021
You can say it like this:
usually produces one, but sometimes multiple, binary outputs.
Answered by Barmar on December 21, 2021
I would just use an extra sentence.
A logic gate performs a binary operation and produces a binary output. Most gates have a single output, but some have multiple outputs.
Answered by The Photon on December 21, 2021
Get help from others!
Recent Questions
Recent Answers
© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP