TransWikia.com

have still to vs still have to

English Language & Usage Asked by nt06 on November 11, 2020

” researchers have still to decide whether smell is one sense or two- one responding to odours proper and the registering odourless chemicals in the air. ”
Can I ask you guys why it’s not still have to in this sentence ?

4 Answers

It's not "still have to" because, in this case, the placement of still is optional; it can go before or after the verb.

Answered by Michael Harvey on November 11, 2020

My guess the rule is it goes before the verb, but still makes sense when used after. It's like six of one and half a dozen of another.

Answered by Ashok on November 11, 2020

The meaning is slightly different.

The "have still to" form means that the action is required and as yet not performed.

The "still have to" form means that the requirement for the action is still in force. It does not say whether the action has been performed in the current instance.

Example: You cannot go to your party yet. You have still to clean your room.

Your room must be cleaned before you go to the party. You have not yet done so.

Example: Now that you have reached the age of 16, you have some additional privileges. But you still have to clean your room before you go to any party.

The requirement to clean your room has not been removed. There may or may not be a particular party being discussed at this time.

Answered by puppetsock on November 11, 2020

Current best answer appears to be by user339660 almost a year ago in comments. So moved to the answer below:

Still can go in either position but still have to is much more common.

Have still to can sound quite stiff and old-fashioned but it is still used.

There is a slight nuance in that:

They still have to X

Means they have to X and they haven't yet, whereas:

They have still to X

Can just mean they haven't yet X (like they have yet to X, which doesn't imply any obligation at all).

In this context there isn't really any difference between those meanings and I would say it's just a question of style.

Answered by Gary on November 11, 2020

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP