TransWikia.com

"exerts and responds to forces to/from their surrounding"": how to revise?

English Language & Usage Asked on January 28, 2021

I want to say

"[…] such as how it exerts forces to their surrounding and responds to forces from their surrounding"

However, I do not want to repeat "forces to their surrounding" twice, so but if I connect "exerts" and "responds" together, then I won’t be able to change the preposition "to/from" coming after "forces".

So, how can revise this sentence in a compact what so that I won’t need to repeat "forces to their surrounding" twice?

3 Answers

The only way I can think of is

It exerts forces to and responds to forces from their surrounding

But I am only risking it in fact. A native speaker might be able to tell us if "acrobacies" of such kind are acceptable.

You can certainly try and find synonyms of forces so as not to stumble on its repetition:

It exerts forces to and responds to impacts from their surrounding

Note: I have respected the precise context you have given but actually the more idiomatic phrase is

to exert force(s) (singular is more common) on something

Answered by fev on January 28, 2021

As commented earlier, an appropriate word is interaction.

The key to this is the prefix inter:

inter = a prefix occurring in loanwords from Latin, where it meant “between,” “among,” “in the midst of,” “mutually,” “reciprocally,” “together,” “during” (intercept; interest); on this model, used in the formation of compound words (intercom; interdepartmental).

Dictionary.com

I emphasize the mention of reciprocity, that is of reciprocal action. An interaction therefore cannot be one way. It necessarily involves action of one on the other, and vice versa.

From this perspective I argue that if "It" (whatever it may be) interacts with its surroundings, each affects the other. "It" exerts a force on the surroundings and they exert a force on "it". In classical physics this is a trivial statement consistent with one of Newton's laws. If the force is more metaphorical than in physics the mutuality is still interactive.

"It interacts with its surroundings." says what needs to be said.

Answered by Anton on January 28, 2021

I'm not sure what it and their refer to, but I think you might need to make them agree—either it/its or they/their. As for the compact wording, try:

[...] such as how it responds to and exerts forces in its surroundings

[...] such as how they respond to and exert forces in their surroundings

To expand it back out:

[...] such as how it responds to forces in its surroundings and exerts forces in its surroundings

Answered by Tinfoil Hat on January 28, 2021

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP