English Language & Usage Asked on February 18, 2021
Your Dictionary Grammar states that ‘main verbs’ are also known as finite verbs. However, I can easily find a few instances where a main verb isn’t the finite verb of the sentence.
Example: We are learning math
‘Learning’ is the main verb but ‘are’ functions as a finite verb.
Am I misunderstanding something, or is the website unreliable?
We are learning math.
Whether "writing" is called a main verb or not depends on the kind of analysis adopted. There are two kinds: the dependent-auxiliary analysis where the core auxiliary verbs are dependents of the following lexical verb, and the catenative-auxiliary analysis, where the core auxiliaries are verbs taking non-finite complements.
Under the dependent-auxiliary analysis, your example is a simple clause. Core auxiliaries are contrasted with main verbs, so that "are learning" is a syntactic unit in which "learning" is called the main (i.e. head) verb head and the core auxiliary "are" is a dependent. The core auxiliaries are thus never heads in the dependent-auxiliary analysis.
By contrast, under the catenative-auxiliary analysis, "learning math" is a non-finite complement of "are". The tree structure therefore has "learning" as a lexical verb and "are" as an auxiliary. On this view, there is no contrast between auxiliary verbs and main verbs. "Are" is just as much a main verb as "learning": both are heads of their respective clauses.
Modern grammar tends to favour the catenative-auxiliary analysis.
Answered by BillJ on February 18, 2021
Get help from others!
Recent Questions
Recent Answers
© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP