TransWikia.com

Definition of "belief system"

English Language & Usage Asked by Yuri Geinish on January 19, 2021

According to https://www.collinsdictionary.com/dictionary/english/belief-system,

The belief system of a person or society is the set of beliefs that they have about what is right and wrong and what is true and false.

The first part, about right and wrong, reflects a person’s goals and is entirely subjective.

The second part, however, looks to be about objective reality, as whether something is true or false isn’t based on one’s wishes, but on how things, in fact, are, unless we’re talking about formal logic which operates on statements, not real life objects.

The second part makes the term "belief system" contradictory and thus unusable, yet I’m hearing it being mentioned quite often. I assume this particular definition is simply wrong and does not reflect what other people mean when using it.

What is the most popular meaning behind it, then? Perhaps it simply means a set of core goals/values that define the rest of that person’s actions?

2 Answers

I believe that a belief system is more subtle and less well-defined than you suggest. Judgements about right and wrong are not simple, and are not necessarily part of personal goals and objectives. To believe that it is wrong to covet another's spouse does not inhibit many people from their aim of enthusiastic adultery.

Nor is the distinction between true and false objective. There are still people who believe that the Earth is flat, despite all evidence to the contrary. There are those who believe that vaccination is part of a subjugating conspiracy, despite there being no evidence to support such an idea. There are people who believe capitalism is the best system, and others who condemn it. Brexit is pure genius; Brexit is stupid self-harm. And so on ...

A google search will easily reveal some of the complexities and varieties of "belief system". Essentially, it is a set of personal beliefs that condition how a person thinks, how they act, how they relate to others, what they think is morally good or bad, what mental model they have of the world. It may rest on sound principles and reflection on evidence or it may rest on prejudice and blind faith even in the face of good evidence to the contrary.

Answered by Anton on January 19, 2021

The second part, however, looks to be about objective reality,

I see this as an error: It is nothing to do with objective reality: it says "The belief system of a person [...] is the set of beliefs that they have" I may believe that black cats are unlucky; that there are gods, fairies and gnomes; I may believe that if I jump up and down three times, I will never have a cold.

Answered by Greybeard on January 19, 2021

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP