TransWikia.com

Could you please explain the meaning of "retaining wall relation"?

English Language & Usage Asked by Sophie on January 8, 2021

"there is a retaining-wall relation between language and group.
"

I looked up the retaining wall (Retaining walls are relatively rigid walls used for supporting soil laterally so that it can be retained at different levels on the two sides. Retaining walls are structures designed to restrain soil to a slope that it would not naturally keep to (typically a steep, near-vertical, or vertical slope.)

However, I found it hard for me to understand what kind of relation is retaining wall relations?

3 Answers

From Course Hero,

As I said at the start, there is a retaining-wall relation between language and group. To speak a language is to take on a world, a culture.

The author continues,

The Antilles Negro who wants to be white will be the whiter as he gains greater mastery of the cultural tool that language is. [In this case, the French language.]

So there is no mystery here. Read the entire article for more explanation. You can find it by entering "there is a retaining-wall relation between language and group" in a Google search (including quotation marks).

Answered by Mark Hubbard on January 8, 2021

This question is about an analogy.

Soil on a slope has a natural tendency to disperse downhill and is prevented from doing so by the boundary of a retaining wall.

Languages have a natural tendency to disperse by intermarriage, cultural exchange, conquest, trade and migration. They may be prevented from doing so by geographical boundaries such as rivers, deserts, mountain ranges and oceans).

More relevant to this question are the boundaries to the dispersion of languages imposed by human groups. Nation states, ethnic groups, tribes, religious groups and others may create boundaries to the dispersion of languages either by rigidly policed physical frontiers or by ingrained human (ethnic, religious, tribal) attitudes.

Whatever their nature, these human boundaries between groups inhibit the natural dispersal of language, in a way that is analogous to the inhibition of natural downslope soil movement by retaining walls.

Answered by Anton on January 8, 2021

I think this figurative idea has to be construed faithfully on the model of the literal meaning. In this meaning an element, earth, has a natural propensity to occupy as much space as is available, to spread to as much territory as there is in its proximity and thus to lose its initial spatial distribution, its shape. It is the wall that prevents that from happening. In the figurative meaning, particularising the analogy on the getting out of shape level, language (more or less loose earth), is found to be a mass with the tendency to lose its function, to be eroded by various agents and the group action to prevent that is that of a propping up by a sheer forcing into "shape". Here the action of the group and the group are identified so that the group is the wall.

However, from what a comment suggests to me (user Jim) the same relation in the other way is quite an appealing possibility. Possibly, both relations have been meant.

Answered by LPH on January 8, 2021

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP