TransWikia.com

Confusing use of 'up to'

English Language & Usage Asked by Dipankar on January 6, 2021

You can cancel the tickets up to thirty minutes before the scheduled departure of the train.

Is the use of ‘up to’semantically correct? Or, is ‘at least’ more appropriate to replace ‘up to’?

Should it be rewritten to make the sense clearer in following manner?

You can cancel the tickets any time but at least thirty minutes before the scheduled departure of the train.

2 Answers

Is the use of 'up to' semantically correct?

Yes.

Or, is 'at least' more appropriate to replace 'up to'?

No.

Should it be rewritten to clear the sense in following manner?

No.

up - adverb = upwards (indicating an advance motion, place or time.)

to - preposition

to + substantive = modifier.

Up to + substantive = adverb.

Answered by Greybeard on January 6, 2021

You can cancel the tickets up to thirty minutes before the scheduled departure of the train.

Here "up to" means time going forwards or "until".

You can cancel the tickets any time but at least thirty minutes before the scheduled departure of the train.

Which is it? "any time" or "at least thirty minutes before"? It says one thing then immediately contradicts itself. People don't always have time to struggle through complex grammar when they need an answer to the question "Can I cancel my ticket right now?" This is a real world problem, not a thought experiment. The simplest grammar is preferable.

Answered by CJ Dennis on January 6, 2021

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP