English Language & Usage Asked by Eduardo Galvão Junior on January 2, 2021
I’m translating a fantasy novel into English. In the story there are a bunch of races. Among them, there are mixed-race people. "Pure races" mock mixed-race people and usually refer to them as ‘mongrels‘. Now, taking into consideration that this word is also used to describe dogs that live on the streets, would it be awkward for humans?
I picked this word intentionally to bring a bad connotation to mind; I want the reader to feel how prejudiced the races are. The original word is "mestiço" in Portuguese.
As @Green Grasso Holm said in her answer, mongrel can be used for a person. But, as many others commented, it is an extremely offensive term when applied to a person. (And it is an insult to many mixed breed dogs, who tend to be every bit as intelligent and fine in character as purebreds.)
As long as you make it absolutely clear that this is a offensive term used by a racist society or by the bad guys in your story, you may get away with it.
I wondered if Mr. Spock, half human and half Vulcan, was ever called a mongrel in Star Trek, so I asked on Science Fiction and Fantasy Stack Exchange: Was Spock ever called a mongrel in a Star Trek TV episode or movie?
The answer by @Buzz is No, although Spock was called a half-breed in three episodes. According to a comment by @wcullen, Spock was referred to as a mongrel in a non-canon novel Shocks of Adversity, but non-canon doesn't count among Star Trek aficionados. Finally, there was an interview with Leonard Nimoy, who played Spock, in which he calls Spock a mongrel, but the wording is ambiguous and Nimoy may possibly be saying that Vulcans regarded Spock as a mongrel. Or not.
I've gone into all this detail on Spock because he is the most famous mixed-species person in all of science fiction, perhaps in all literature, and standards were much more lax when Star Trek came out. So the conclusion is:
As far as the English goes, you can use it, but be careful if you do use it.
Correct answer by ab2 on January 2, 2021
It's a perfect word to describe a person of mixed origins if you intend for it to be pejorative.
Merriam Webster mentions its applicability to persons. https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/mongrel
1 : an individual resulting from the interbreeding of diverse breeds (see breed 1) or strains (see strain 1); especially : one of unknown ancestry She owns several dogs, one of which is a mongrel.
2 : a cross between types of persons or things.
Answered by Green Grasso Holm on January 2, 2021
I know, coming from the British Isles, after invasions from Anglos, Saxons, Normans and and Danes - to names a few. I don't regard myself as pure bred as I see the the Welsh - pure Britons to or the Scots or Bretons. I regard myself as a mongrel as an assimilation of mixed race. My Serbian wife and her family, however, despite the communist influence consider themselves as pure Serbian, despite the fact that the family come from Croatia and Bosnia. Mongrel is a proud badge to wear. . . .and it means we can celebrate all feasts, anywhere. But I still reserve the right to take the piss out of the Church of exclusivity. I love the feast of 25th December, a mixture is pagans and god bothered new year and the Orthodox festivals as well - I get pissed to them all and really love Chinese New Year because it's on a different date Evey year. ...a kind of random bonus. . ...I can't wait for Ramadan to end. . . that's a really good piss up
Answered by Philip Cooper on January 2, 2021
Get help from others!
Recent Answers
Recent Questions
© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP