“Based on” X, we can say Y?

Question

Based on the evidence available, I’m not sure I can conclude anything.

We often say that X is based on Y to mean X is grounded in, or adapted from, Y. But can we use it as above as if it were a sort of absolute construction meaning “because or in light of”? I’ve seen a few such examples but have only just wondered if they were correct.

Elliot · Answer

Logic is introduced with syllogisms such as "Whenever A then B. Now we have A and so we can expect B" The same could apply if A means we will never have C.
Your statement says that they can conclude nothing based on the current circumstances. They fail to describe what requirements they have for some conclusion. The sentence is meaningful and not spurious but it walks away from logic and throws up its hands.

“Based on” X, we can say Y?

One Answer

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question