English Language & Usage Asked on September 2, 2021
I came across the following in the Wall Street Journal, as part of the main story (not the headline),
… Swiss voted narrowly against more hunting, by 52% to 48% …
… Last year, Swiss voted on increasing the stock of low-cost housing, …
Does that mean I can refer to adjective-denoted nationalities without "the," e.g.
French love good food.
Spanish know how to have fun.
Does that mean I can refer to adjective-denoted nationalities without "the,"
No.
This is journalese and is usually limited to headlines. It also requires a certain form of context.
Hello John.
Hello Mary. Can you tell me a fact about France.
French love good food. (incorrect)
The French love good food (correct)
French love good food says Macron!
When being interviewed last night, president Macron was asked what he liked most about being French. "We the people of France, love good food!" He proclaimed.
Answered by chasly - supports Monica on September 2, 2021
No, you cannot do that. The reason is somewhat trickier than you might imagine.
So to start with, of course you can say this:
Because it’s here the name of a language, Spanish takes a singular verb.
But you cannot say:
That’s illegal. Since adjectives in English lack number, they cannot be the subject of a clause.
Instead you must use a plural noun and say:
By using a plural noun, this of course takes a plural verb.
However, when you write:
You do not have an adjective as the subject. And yet the word Spanish there is not a noun, either.
And this is where it gets a bit tricky.
What you do have is a clause that uses a fused-head modifier as its subject. The fusion is that the actual head of the noun phrase, some sort of noun, has fused into the modifier, but it is still a noun phrase nonetheless and so can be the subject of a clause. What it has fused with is some plural noun like people, which is why it still takes plural concord.
This is the same thing that happens with fused-head constructions like these:
None of those sentences has any nouns in it. You can apply intensifiers to adjectives but not to nouns, and those can all take intensifiers without a hitch:
If those had been nouns, you could not have done that. Since you can do that, those are not nouns. They are adjectives forming part of fused-head constructions. The original nouns are fused and gone.
If you want to use just an adjective and have that be an entire noun phrase, you need to have a determiner precede it to signal that the head noun has been fused.
There are other types of fused heads than adjectives, but we can save those for some other day.
Answered by tchrist on September 2, 2021
Get help from others!
Recent Answers
Recent Questions
© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP