TransWikia.com

A tough choice between two alternatives

English Language & Usage Asked on August 6, 2020

I’m native Russian and when we need to talk about some tough choice between two alternatives, we use a metaphor of a traditional scale. Namely, it’s bowls.

  • Так вышло, что на одной чаше весов был чемпионат мира, а на другой — дружба.

  • In English: It so happened that the World Championship was on one side of the scales, and friendship was on the other.

Idioms are generally very regional-specific, and so I think it won’t be a good idea to translate it to English literally. What will be a good alternative for it?

I know about "on the one hand …, on the other one …", but it’s not quite the same.

2 Answers

On the horns of a dilemma

This emphasizes the difficulty of a choice. To my mind it suggests that the decision will have negative consequences in one, but not both directions. This point of view may seem at first sight difficult to reconcile with the common dictionary definition:

"to choose between two things, both of which are unpleasant or difficult"

However, applied to the example from the poster the choice between the two unpleasant things is a choice between “not going to the World Championships” and “losing a friendship”. In each case the choice results in a partial positive outcome — “going to the World Championships” or “maintaining a friendship”.

More negative in both directions (to my mind) might be the rather overused:

Between a rock and a hard place

Neither seem to me quite as negative as the “lose-lose” of @RichardKayser, although I think his “no-win” is possible.

Metaphoric use of ‘balance’ in English

There are several metaphors using balances or scales in English, but those that come to mind relate solely to the outcome (the heavier or favoured balance pan) when the equilibrium is disturbed, rather than nature of the possible outcomes (the contents of the balance pans). Thus, we have:

Finely balanced
In the balance

…relating to the uncertainty of the outcome, and:

Tip the balance in favour of…
On balance

…relating to the actual outcome. Although, somewhat counter-intuitively, the balance itself (as in financial usage) has come to mean the difference between the weights in the two pans.

Correct answer by David on August 6, 2020

How about lose-lose situation? From Cambridge:

lose-lose: A lose-lose situation or result is one that is bad for everyone who is involved: He said that going ahead with the strike would be a lose-lose situation for all concerned.

One could also call this a no-win situation, a situation that has no ideal solution.

Answered by Richard Kayser on August 6, 2020

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP