TransWikia.com

Why would a "delayed loudspeaker" be so expensive in the 1970s?

Engineering Asked by Silven B. on January 13, 2021

Recently, I read about some major musical concert held somewhere in the USA to a record-large audience.

Since there were so many people, not all could see or even hear the music from the main loudspeakers.

Therefore, they put additional loudspeakers far away from the scene, connected with cables from the main equipment at the stage (presumably).

Since sound travels slower in the air than electrical signals inside cables, the music coming out from the far-away loudspeakers would have been out of sync with the actual sound waves, unless they did this "clever trick".

The clever trick apparently consisted of them spending a huge amount of money ("the cost of a new car per loudspeaker") on then-cutting edge electronics which delayed the signal exactly so that it would match the sound waves, and thus not cause disharmony.

While this made me think of how clever that sounds, I don’t understand why exactly this would be so costly, even if it was in the early 1970s. In fact, I don’t understand why it had to be so technical at all. It seems like this could’ve been accomplished in some analogue manner, very cheaply. The cost of a new car, many times over? Really?

What made it cost so much money? And had nobody ever held a big enough concert before this relatively late date, which would warrant a similar solution?

Did they have concerts for many years which sounded bad for the people far away, because the real audio waves were mixed (unsynced) with the local loudspeakers?

And if they barely heard the music so far anyway, did it really matter at all? Or was this more of a way to sell tickets by claiming a "perfect hi-fi-quality experience for every single participant"?

(Sorry I can’t remember the name of the concert; I thought I had it bookmarked.)

One Answer

The band was the Grateful Dead and the invention necessary was an analog delay line that was inserted between the main audio mix signal line and the power amps that drove the speaker arrays (which were co-located with the speakers themselves). Delays on order of a tenth to a half a millisecond were needed and the amount of delay had to be adjustable to within a hundredth of a millisecond and locked to that setting with less than one percent of drift on timescales of a quarter of a second.

In the early 70's this would require all-custom design as no off-the-shelf components were available, and digital means of processing audio signals did not exist. I do not know what the delay systems cost.

Answered by niels nielsen on January 13, 2021

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP