Engineering Asked on December 14, 2021
W and H sections look pretty much the same. S and I sections have their flanges rounded. What difference does this rounding make, why would an S-section be used instead of W-section for example?
Sloping flange has lower flange length to thickness ratio than a counteeoart W section. It results in a higher allowable flexural strength. The drawback however is in bolting of the flanges as they are sloping.
Answered by Perfecto B. Padilla Jr on December 14, 2021
For clarity, it's helpful to make the distinction between talking generally about "H-shaped" and "I-shaped" members, which is somewhat vague, versus the actual designations of standardized rolled shapes. The AISC Steel Construction Manual includes section information for standard W, S, HP, and M rolled shapes that will be fairly commonly available from steel mills (some shapes more than others). Each shape has different cross-sectional proportions and available size ranges, and will thus be best suited for different applications.
Each section is identified by the shape designation, the approximate depth, and the weight per foot. For example, W24x62 is a wide flange beam, 24.5" deep and weighing 62 lb/ft.
I don't have a definitive answer for this. To my knowledge the profile now designated as "S-" does predate the profile now designated as "W-". It may be that fabrication capabilities and material limitations drove things. It might also stem from the "S-" shape having its roots in the rail industry, or even be a reflection of the transition from cast iron to hot-rolled steel. Researching the history of steel companies and ASTM standards might nail down the exact whys and wherefores of the evolution of structural steel shapes, but it's an effort without much practical benefit. The bottom line is things evolved over time and today W- sections generally meet the needs of designers looking for rolled beam sections.
Answered by CableStay on December 14, 2021
Get help from others!
Recent Answers
Recent Questions
© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP