Is it hotter in different places with the same air temperature?

Question

I am from (and live in) Minnesota, USA. In the summer here it always reaches temperatures in the 90s (F) for periods of time but not every week. The humidity is often high and the dew point often tropical.

My wife is from Guangdong province in the south east region of China. The temperature there most closely resembles Florida, USA. It is usually in the 90s during the summer instead of sometimes. It is always humid and feels tropical.

My wife, her friends and family routinely comment on how incredibly hot it is in China. They say people often don't even go outside because it's so hot. They say it is not like Minnesota, but much worse.

My question then... how? Is this merely perception of growing up in a tropical environment without artificial climate control or is there science that backs up their claims? If our regions are the same air temperature with similar humidity and dew points, I don't understand how it can feel so much hotter there.

dlb · Accepted Answer

A temperature is a temperature but the effect of that temperature is not always the same. Some things that add to our perception include sun intensity, wind, humidity, and simply what we are used to. The Humidex as mentioned by Trevor, or some other forms of heat indexes are attempts to measure how the temperature feels as compared to what it actually is, and its effects on animals and plants, very similarly to wind chill charts in the winter. In Minnesota, you should relate to not all temperatures of -10 being created equal, that how hard the wind is blowing matters too. The temperature is the same, but the cooling effect when the wind is blowing harder is much greater so it feels colder and the damaging effects of the cold can occur much more quickly. The same is true on the other side, with higher heat indexes at the same air temperature, animals and plants can suffer heat damage more quickly.

Correct answer by dlb on August 21, 2021

Trevor J. Smith · Answer

While perceptions about the climate can have an effect on how we react to our environment, Guangdong and Minnesota are fundamentally different climates altogether. Using the Koppen-Geiger climate classification system, Minnesota is mostly a Temperate Continental (Dfb/Dwb) climate, meaning that is has warm summers and long cold winters, while Guangdong is a Humid Subtropical (Cfa/Cwa) climate with hot and wet summers and a short dry winter. The classification is largely based on monthly average temperatures and precipitations based on climate normals (~30-year periods).

It might be the case that temperatures match up at some points, but based on the classifications/geography of both areas, it would seem that Guangdong experiences more humidity and much longer warm periods, which combined would raise the Humidex (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Humidex) above that of Minnesota.

For more information on the Koppen-Geiger classification, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/K%C3%B6ppen_climate_classification

Semidiurnal Simon · Answer

Compare your descriptions of the two climates:

In the summer here [Minnesota] it always reaches temperatures in the 90s (F) for
  periods of time but not every week. The humidity is often high and the
  dew point often tropical.
  
  [In Guangdong] It is usually in the 90s during the summer instead of
  sometimes. It is always humid and feels tropical.

You're saying that sometimes Minnesota is as hot as Guangdong usually is.
Thus (based only on this info) Guangdong probably has a higher mean temperature.
Assuming there is some variability around that mean, it seems likely that Guangdong also has a higher maximum temperature. Thus, Guangdong might be perceived as hotter.

Cultural factors might also contribute to the perception of difference, such as the type of clothing worn, the prevalence of air conditioning, or the activities that the people in question are typically undertaking in each place.

P Harold Bobo Eveline · Answer

I would say, that given the same temperature humidity index and wind. It would be that person's perception. Un less you are out on a boat, or under a tree or surrounded by buildings and such. Other that that, I say we all come back here with some science.

Answered by P Harold Bobo Eveline on August 21, 2021

Is it hotter in different places with the same air temperature?

4 Answers

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question