Bicycles Asked on April 5, 2021
I had some intermittent clanking noise on yesterday’s ride, thought the chain just needed cleaning and derailleur aligning. But got home to find that one side of one chain link had broken, so only the other side was holding the chain together. The broken side was occasionally clanking against some of the drivetrain components.
I had pushed my 110kg system weight uphill and out of the saddle, which got me wondering how much strain the broken link could have taken.
Are chains designed to withstand a certain amount of force along their length, and how much would a half-broken link compromise that? Or is it when a chain bends around sprockets that it’s more vulnerable, not just straight-line force?
Edit – I suppose the half link question is whether a chain actually loses any ‘strength’ if only one side panel is present on a link, or whether the dual side panel design is solely to locate the chain over the teeth. I’m thinking it would lose some strength, but nowhere near what I would imagine, and probably much less than half its original strength.
The design tensile strength of bicycle chains is probably in excess of what almost all humans can reasonably hope to output. I'm not aware of publicly available figures for this parameter, and I'd assume that the manufacturer specifications are their trade secrets. Adam Kerin of Zero Friction Cycling is in the process of testing tensile strength, so if you are interested in this, you could watch this page. *
I'm not an engineer, but once the chain fails on one side, the force on the other side presumably increases by up to double. Plus the whole structure would get pulled sideways and fail as the pin gets pulled out of the other roller and link plate. That chain is done. Don't ride it.
Notice that the first paragraph said the design tensile strength. As with any manufacturing process, you will occasionally get dud items. Alternatively, if the chain was joined by a master pin, the mechanic in question might have mis-installed it. This is not so much a veiled swipe at you as it is a general statement of human fallibility. I haven't broken a master pin, but that's only because I don't use pins. I quite recently incorrectly connected a master link by failing to engage one side. The link failed in much the same way I'd expect your chain to fail if you keep pedaling it.
* -In summary, the page insists a chain can take up to 9kN before failing. This is equivalent to 900kg static load (standing still onto the pedals). Or perhaps 450kg when sprinting.
Correct answer by Weiwen Ng on April 5, 2021
Chains do withstand all reasonable forces you can put at them. Current chains are bushingless design where the punched side plates have a half-bushing on each side. Not having a press fit bushing but integral bushing-halves, the bushing doesn't weaken the chain and the chain withstands a huge amount of force.
There are people weighing over 150 kg riding bikes standing on the pedals. The first thing that fails for them isn't the chain, it's poorly built wheels.
There are mountain bikers using chainrings as ridiculously small as 20 teeth. This gives more mechanical advantage for the crank chainring system, thus increasing chain loads. Chains don't regularly fail for them.
There are e-bikes that have pedaling assist at the cranks (mid-drive), thus increasing chain loads. Those e-bikes don't require e-bike-specific chains (except sometimes you see e-bike specific components; that's just marketers wanting to sell more expensive stuff -- normal bike components work just fine for e-bikes)
It's the straight upper run of the chain that bears the load. Once the chain turns around the sprocket, the load immediately reduces because the first tooth carries most of the load. The chain links flexing cause chains to wear, but the greatest forces are encountered in the straight upper run.
Thus, I'd say your chain had a manufacturing defect that caused at least one link to be weaker than it's supposed to be and thus caused the chain to fail. This isn't entirely uncommon.
Answered by juhist on April 5, 2021
Bicycle chain plates are typically made of steel. Steel has very high tensile strength. For chain tension to permanently deform a chain link plate (permanently stretch but not break), the tensile force would likely have to be at least 200 lbf per plate. The ultimate strength of the plate (causing a break, not just permanent stretch) would typically be 2-3 times as much. In actual use, bicycle chain plates don't stretch (the observed chain stretch is primarily the wearing down of the pin-bushing interface surfaces).
Answered by robartsd on April 5, 2021
Get help from others!
Recent Questions
Recent Answers
© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP