Broken Sturmey-Archer dual cable 5-speed shifter

According to Sheldon Brown the two cable 5 speed hubs were made in 1991-1992 in a freewheel and drum brake model called the 5 Star and the 5 Star Elite w/drum brake. He lists the features for these hubs as:

Two cables: unreliable, cantilevered pinion pins

Further

The weak point of the 2-cable 5-speed hubs was the shift control units. The S5 required a taut cable to prevent the primary sun gear from disengaging from the axle in first gear. Sturmey-Archer went through a number of top-tube mounted shift levers, which were never very satisfactory mechanically. The left-side cable needed to be very carefully adjusted, and the actual mechanics of the click stops in the two-lever controls were too weak, so they were quite unreliable, even though there was no real problem with the hubs.

Sheldon's recommendation:

The best control arrangement for a 2-cable 5-speed hub is a standard 3-speed trigger for the right cable, and a friction-type derailleur shift lever for the left cable. The use of the friction shifter on the left gets around the problem of critical adjustment of the left cable, since you just pull it until it stops.

Sheldon does link to a diagram with the two types of shift levers for this hub containing the part numbers. Sturmey Archer does not make them anymore so the only hope you have of finding an actual replacement is used or New Old Stock.