How does this timing aboard the Obra Dinn make sense?

In Return of the Obra Dinn, looking through some of the death scenes, I am perplexed as to how the timing works.

In Escape I, we hear the captain has just come up from the hold after chasing away the monster, and we see people (including the captain) emerging from the lower decks. The dialogue seems to indicate that very little time has passed since the end of Doom. In (chronologically) later Escape scenes, we see that the captain comes across four people escaping in the last boat, and one escapee being killed.

However, in The Bargain, we see the captain

How did they do all of that in the time it took the captain to walk up two decks?