How can I make Talking Skull patrons happiest during events?

The Stranger Sins DLC adds the Talking Skull tavern, and with it the ability to host events. Selling beverages and dishes during these events can generate a lot of revenue.

There’s a lot of talk in other discussion forums (Reddit, Steam, etc.) about how to maximize profits during these events, and all suggest that each event type has some combination of certain food and drinks that patrons will really like, thereby boosting patron happiness and profits. However, there seems to be no definitive list. The Talking Skull’s wiki page (link) has a list of foods, but it looks like there are duplicate items.

What dishes should I use for each event in order to boost patron happiness at the Talking Skull? Also, can one have lots of just one type of food or drink on that list, or does there need to be variety?