Do players get better by being played with the same profile?

Me and my friend play FIFA 12 at an arcade. He thinks by playing the game with the same profile over and over (in kick-off mode) will increase the performance of the players. I however think this is not true. Since we are playing at an arcade I believe that some player might have increased the performance of the players.

I checked the user gameplay settings in game setting and found something like this (Image is taken from my PC). Could this be the reason?

I would like to know what the case is: Do players get better performance when playing with the same profile more often or not?