Physics Asked on January 28, 2021
I’m trying to show that the mass-luminosity for a fully convective star is
$$L propto M^{frac{113}{66}}$$
I know that the energy generation is via pp-chain and the opacity is due to $H^{-}$ ions such that:
$epsilon = epsilon_0 rho T^3$ and $kappa = kappa_0rho^{1/2}T^9$
I use the equation of stellar structure:
hydrostatic equilibrium: $P propto M^2/R^4$
equation of state: $P propto rho^{5/3}$
energy generation: $L propto R^3rho epsilon$
and there’s obviously that $rho propto M/R^3$ and the ideal gas $P propto rho T$.
I can’t use the equation of radiative transfer, because the star is convective but I instead have the equation of state, assuming the star is isentropic due to being fully convective. These together result in
$$L propto M^7$$ which is not even close. Also in my calculation I never utilize the opacity relation, as it only really comes up in the radiative transport equation.
Any ideas where I’m going wrong?
The bit you are missing is that the radius of the star is determined by the opacity.
Hydrostatic equilibrium yields $$P_R = frac{GM}{R^2}int rho dr,$$ where $P_R$ is the pressure at the radius where light can escape. This in turn is related to the opacity $kappa$ by $$int kappa rho dr = bar{kappa}int rho dr = 1$$ Thus $$P_R = frac{GM}{R^2bar{kappa}} propto frac{GM}{R^2 rho^a T_{rm eff}^b}, tag*{(1)}$$ where I have substituted in $bar{kappa}propto rho_R^a T_{rm eff}^b$.
With this equation you also have $$ L = 4pi R^2 sigma T_{rm eff}^4 tag*{(2)}$$ $$ L propto M rho T^c tag*{(3)}$$
From the virial theorem and perfect gas law you also know that the interior $T propto M/R$ and interior $rho propto M/R^3$.
You thus have 6 variables $L, M, R, T_{rm eff}$, $P_R$, $rho_R$ and 3 equations. To eliminate all but $L$ and $M$ you need another.
This comes from the interior polytropic equation of state $P propto rho^{gamma}$ for a fully convective star (a polytrope with $gamma = 5/3$ for a fully convective star). However, this proportionality only applies to a particular star - the constant of proportionality in fact depends on the mass and radius of the star in question. Here is not the place to repeat textbooks that deal with polytropes, but it can be shown that (e.g. here) $$Prho^{-gamma} propto P^{1-gamma} T^{gamma} propto M^{2-gamma} R^{3gamma -4}$$ and thus near the surface $$P_R^{1 -gamma} T_{rm eff}^{gamma} propto M^{2 -gamma} R^{3gamma-4} tag*{(4)}$$
You then solve to get $L$ only as a function of $M$ and substitute in $gamma=5/3$ and your favourite values for $a$, $b$ and $c$.
Answered by ProfRob on January 28, 2021
Get help from others!
Recent Questions
Recent Answers
© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP